Are “Non-Toxic” Ceramic Pans Really Safe?

Ceramic nonstick pans are everywhere. Scroll through Instagram and you’ll see Caraway, Our Place’s Always Pan, or GreenPan; the stylish, pastel-colored, “non-toxic” alternatives to Teflon.

But “ceramic” doesn’t mean a kiln-fired glaze. Most of these pans use a sol-gel coating, a liquid chemical mix that hardens into a slick, glassy layer on top of aluminum. It looks clean, but once you dig into what’s inside and how it wears, some clear risks show up.

PFAS confusion

Brands love to say they’re “PFOA-free.” But PFOA is just one member of the much larger PFAS family, the “forever chemicals” tied to cancer, hormone disruption, and water contamination. Some sol-gel coatings have still used fluorinated additives anyway.

The safest claim to look for is fluorine-free (fluorine is the element at the heart of PFAS), ideally backed by independent testing. California’s new AB-1200 law even restricts how cookware brands market “PFAS-free” and requires them to disclose intentionally added chemicals online.

The Manufacturer’s “Secret Recipe”

The second red flag: Each brand has its own proprietary coating. Patents show blends of siloxanes and alkoxysilanes, sometimes even fluorinated ingredients to make them more slippery. But you won’t find those details on a product page. Shoppers are left with vague “non-toxic” marketing and little transparency, meaning you can’t verify whether you’re being exposed to risky additives at all.

Nanoparticles in the mix

Independent studies have found titanium dioxide and silica nanoparticles in ceramic coatings. Once the coating is scratched, or when you simmer acidic foods like tomato sauce, those particles can migrate into food simulants.

Titanium dioxide is controversial: Europe banned it as a food additive in 2021 because of unresolved safety concerns around DNA damage and long-term health effects. Cookware isn’t food, but if those nanoparticles leach out once coatings wear, they can still end up in your meals.

Built to Wear Out

Tests show sol-gel coatings wear down faster than Teflon. Once the surface roughens, food sticks, you scrape harder, and the coating breaks down even more. Within a year or two, most ceramic pans lose their “nonstick.”

And once that top layer is compromised, the aluminum base underneath is exposed. Aluminum migration into food increases with heat, salt, and acidity, and high intake has been tied to neurotoxicity, Alzheimer’s concerns, and bone issues. In other words, when the coating fails, the risks only escalate.

What to Look For Instead

If you want pans that last and don’t come with mystery coatings, stick to the classics:

• Stainless steel – Durable, non-reactive, and great for nearly every cooking task. For those sensitive to nickel, look for lower-nickel blends (like 18/0 or 18/8) and consider paying up for made-in-America brands with tighter quality controls. Stainless won’t give you a slippery nonstick surface, but with the right heat technique you can cook eggs or fish cleanly (see the “mercury ball” water test).

• Cast iron & carbon steel – True forever pans. They develop a natural nonstick patina over time and only get better the more you cook with them. Perfect for searing, baking, and everyday stovetop use.

If you do keep a ceramic pan for convenience, use it gently: keep heat low, avoid metal utensils, and replace it once the coating starts to wear.

The takeaway

We don’t yet know for sure whether ceramic pans pose a health risk. What is clear is that their coatings wear down quickly and aren’t well disclosed. Once that surface breaks down, the chances of chemicals or metals migrating into your food rise.

Ceramic nonstick pans are basically the fast fashion of cookware: trendy, colorful, and short-lived. For real longevity and transparency, the safest bet is cookware without coatings. Cast iron, carbon steel, and stainless steel will only improve with time, while ceramic pans are best thought of as temporary tools.

Lovebird is on a mission to clean up cereal with organic, real food ingredients, no refined sugar, no seed oils, and nothing artificial.

Use code SOS for 20% off.

What did you think of this newsletter?
Loved it! ❤️
It was ok. 👎

Looking to verify your restaurant on Seed Oil Scout? Tap here to take the survey.

Own a brand and want to advertise to over 500K health conscious consumers? Tap here.