Seed Oil Scout
Weekly

California will card teens for creatine and other “muscle building” supplements

1 scoop of creatine (5 g) equals about 3.5 lb cod, 2.5 lb salmon, 2.5 lb ribeye, 2.2 lb pork chops, or 1.5 lb herring

FOND makes Seed Oil Safe bone broth, beef tallow, lard, and duck fat by hand, from regenerative US farms, in glass jars. 10% off with code SEEDOILSCOUT

What the law does

California's Assembly Bill 2030 bars stores from selling supplements marketed for weight loss or muscle building to anyone under 18. Creatine is one of six named ingredients that can trigger the rule. Each violation can cost a store up to $500.

The law grew out of eating-disorder research. Harvard's STRIPED program, which studies diet-pill harm in teens, backed the bill. In a 2019 study, young women who used diet pills were more than 5 times as likely to receive an eating-disorder diagnosis within 1 to 3 years. Diet pills and fat burners are the real target. The FDA doesn't review supplements before they hit shelves, and some have turned up with hidden stimulants and steroids.

Creatine powder sits on the same shelf. Whether that makes it the same thing is a fair question.

What the research says

The benefits in adults are hard to argue with. The International Society of Sports Nutrition reviewed the literature in 2017 and concluded creatine monohydrate is the most effective nutritional supplement for increasing high-intensity exercise capacity and lean body mass. A 2024 meta-analysis of 16 randomized controlled trials found it may also improve memory and processing speed. The standard study dose is 3 to 5 grams a day.

What's missing: long-term data in teenagers. Most studies followed adults for weeks or months. None tracked a 15-year-old taking multiple scoops daily for years.

It doesn't come from food, or from the United States

Your body makes about 1 gram of creatine a day. Meat-eaters get another 1 to 2 grams from food. The supplement is a different story: factories react two industrial chemicals (sarcosine and cyanamide) in a tank, then crystallize, dry, and grind the result.

Almost all of it is made in China. The one well-known exception is Creapure, produced by Alzchem in Bavaria, Germany, with 99.9% guaranteed purity and Informed Sport certification. It costs more. Generic creatine typically tests between 95% and 99.8% pure, and heavy-metal levels depend on each manufacturer's process controls. A "Made in USA" label usually just means Chinese powder was shipped in and packed here.

How much creatine is in food?

Creatine occurs naturally in meat and fish, and only in meat and fish. Here's what 1 pound of raw meat delivers (cooking reduces it, and medium-rare keeps more than well-done):

Food (1 lb raw)

Creatine

Herring

~3 g

Pork

~2 g

Beef

~2 g

Salmon

~2 g

Cod

~1.5 g

To match the 5 g/day used in studies from food alone, you're looking at about 1.5 lbs of herring or 2.5 lbs of beef, every day. It's doable, but it's a commitment. A pound of red meat or fish at dinner puts you at roughly 3 to 4 grams total when you count what your body already makes. That's squarely within the ISSN's recommended range.

Cook that steak in tallow

If you're putting more meat on the plate, don't fry it in soybean oil. FOND makes the fats and broths your great-grandparents cooked with: beef tallow, pork lard, duck fat, bone broth, and demi-glace. It's all made by hand, from scratch, the way you'd make it at home.

  • Certified regenerative bones and suet, 100% grass-fed or pasture-raised depending on the animal

  • US-only sourcing and manufacturing

  • Packed in glass, never plastic

  • New: beef and chicken demi-glace and duck fat

  • In stores: tallow, duck fat, and bone broth at Whole Foods and Sprouts nationwide

Cooking Thanksgiving dinner? Roast the potatoes in duck fat and build the gravy on FOND bone broth.

👉 10% off with code SEEDOILSCOUT (one-time orders, one use per customer)